The Campaign Isn’t the Strategy


I love autumn. The weather gets cooler. The leaves change color. And marketing managers start imagining what next year’s plans could look like.
Just as the leaves begin to fall, requests for proposals start filling our inboxes, and with them come fresh ideas and opportunities for the year ahead. And while I love seeing those plans come together, autumn is also a good time to do a little cleanup. Not necessarily of the leaves, but of the assumptions we bring into the planning process.
We often hear: “We need to do some social.” “We have money for direct mail.” “We should be doing something on YouTube.”
These may all be true. In fact, they often lead to awesome campaigns. But before we start talking about platforms, targeting, or creative, I like to ask a few questions: What are we trying to change? Who are we trying to reach? Why would your audience be motivated to respond? And how will we know whether it worked?
Because a campaign is something you run. A strategy is the reason you’re running it.
Start With the Objective
One of my favorite parts of working with media brands and event marketers is the conversation that happens before a campaign is built. Are we introducing a morning show to potential listeners? Helping someone discover a podcast? Selling tickets to an event? Encouraging an occasional listener to tune in more often? Each objective presents a different opportunity, and the same marketing approach won’t necessarily work for all of them.
Advertising effectiveness researchers Les Binet and Peter Field analyzed 880 advertising case studies and found that focusing on measurable business objectives was associated with stronger campaign performance. It’s a good reminder that the outcome should help determine the campaign, not the other way around.
Know Who You Are Talking To
Once we have established what we’re trying to accomplish, the next question is whether we’re reaching the people most likely to help us get there.
Two radio stations targeting Women 25–54 in the same market may have completely different opportunities for growth. One may need to introduce itself to compatible listeners who are not familiar with the brand. Another may have strong awareness but need to give occasional listeners more reasons to tune in. The demographic is the same. The audience challenge is not.
This also applies to podcasts and events. Attracting first-time listeners or attendees is a different assignment than encouraging existing fans to engage more often. Understanding those differences shapes the targeting, message, timing, and ultimately the investment.
Reaching the right people matters. Giving them a reason to care matters just as much.

Measure What Matters
We have more campaign data available than ever before. Impressions, clicks, video views, and engagement rates all tell us something. But do they tell us whether we’ve accomplished what we set out to do?
Nielsen’s 2025 Annual Marketing Report found that only 32% of marketers globally measured their traditional and digital media spending together. With audiences moving across so many platforms, getting a complete picture of campaign performance remains a challenge.
For a radio station, success might mean increased listening. For a podcast, new subscribers or more episode consumption. For an event, ticket sales or attracting a new audience. Not every outcome can be measured directly, but we can define what success looks like and determine how we’ll measure progress before the campaign begins.
A million impressions might sound impressive. But what did those impressions accomplish?
Sometimes the Original Plan Is Exactly Right
Sometimes a client comes to us knowing exactly which marketing tactic they want to use. And after talking through the objectives, that original plan may be exactly what we recommend. Other times, we adjust the audience, message, timing, or combination of tactics.
Either way, we’ve connected the investment to a specific opportunity. That is the value of having the conversation and building a strategy before the campaign begins.

A Little Autumn Cleanup
As the leaves continue to fall and next year’s budgets take shape, I’m looking forward to the conversations that will help shape what comes next. Because the most productive part of planning isn’t adding another tactic to the schedule.
And just like the leaves, sometimes a few old assumptions need to be cleared away before something new can grow.
For more information:
Susan Bacich: susan@ptpmarketing.com 201.362.6569





Comments